Laura MercierCaviar Tightline Eyeliner: Long Lasting Color, Crease-proof, Waterproof, Gel-like Hydrating Formula, Perfect for Tightline, Lash Line + Waterline

I love Laura Mercier everything and this is on the top of the list. Stays in place all day, even inside the lash line and doesn’t move to the inside corners of the eye ever ti make for that goopy black eye look. It also smudges great when first applied for a smoky look, but then doesn’t keep smudging throughout the day to places you don’t want it to. This is honestly the best eyeliner I have ever used and I have tried many. It is better than both Make Up Forever’s and NARS and those were the top of my list for quite some time. You will love this! I only wish I didn’t need to sharpen it as I do prefer that Make Up Forever’s waterproof long stay doesn’t need a sharpener.

This is a wonderful eye liner. I'm older and deal with other liners moving into my wrinkles, this one stays put. I am so excited to order other colors. The color is beautiful and it stays on till I take it off. I have a good sharpener and have not had an issue with sharpening the pencil as others had said.

Works well on waterline. I have tried so many eyeliners and finally found one that stays on!

This is one of the best tightliners I've used. Very smooth...no drag, and it lays down a lot pigment on 1st swipe. No, it doesn't stay on all day, but I doubt one exists that does! Pretty happy with this one!

Goes on smooth and stays put! Easy to put on close to lid.

Hard to sharpen. This company had a regular pencil which was great. Went on much easier. I wish companies did not change products that work well.

So far so good. Never used this eyeliner, but I like it after 2 days.

Update: cancel the retire below! I contacted the company and I was apparently trying to sharpen it incorrectly! ??? My bad ! I now am very happy with the product!Old review: “I loved the old Laura Mercier eyeliner and have used it for years. Apparently it has been phased out. I ordered this product 2 months ago. I still had some old product left and started using this new one less than a month ago. I did like the quality but it will not twist or turn to sharpen it. Even my very strong husband tried. That’s money wasted unless there is some refund or replacement.